firedude said:It also seams that Stuart made some mistakes.
hawkspringsfire said:What mistakes did he make? I may have missed it in the video.
firedude said:1- he said that there was 1 red and 1 blue Sound off interector lights. The video shows that both sides are red.
2- he says the whelen liberty was set up with red and amber LEDs. the video shows that the bar is all red with takedowns and allies.
hawkspringsfire said:I see what you mean about the intersector, but the whelen bar could be a duo with both a red and amber configuration?
They need it because it's more important for roads to be safe than just about anything else on a highway (including criminal justice), and amber is pretty much a "disrespect me please" light. They may not be going over the speed limit, but their job is absolutely critical to the preservation of life and property (which is actually the definition of the requirements for a red light permit in PA). Speed is only one small part of running hot, remember that. In order to do their job better and safely, they need to be yielded to.stansdds said:I'd like to know why a DOT thinks it needs to run red and white warning lights, do they think they are fire/ems?
Ipuvaepe said:They need it because it's more important for roads to be safe than just about anything else on a highway (including criminal justice), and amber is pretty much a "disrespect me please" light. They may not be going over the speed limit, but their job is absolutely critical to the preservation of life and property (which is actually the definition of the requirements for a red light permit in PA). Speed is only one small part of running hot, remember that. In order to do their job better and safely, they need to be yielded to.
In the end they may not be fire or EMS, but they are critical to the preservation of life and property (at least during snow removal and the like) just like fire and EMS. I'm not saying that they should have red lights flashing when patching a hole in the road or changing a flat tire, but when keeping the road conditions driveable they absolutely should. Separately switched red and amber would be the best possible solution. Considering amber is 2/3 red, bicolor LEDs in red/amber would also be pretty cheap compared to red/blue etc.
stansdds said:I'd like to know why a DOT thinks it needs to run red and white warning lights, do they think they are fire/ems?
Ipuvaepe said:In order to do their job better and safely, they need to be yielded to.
I wasn't speaking of that vehicle, more the huge F750 dumper/plow DOT trucks, especially ones with a plow trailer. However, you need to realize that a lack of apparent reason is not the same thing a a reason against. You may not see why they should have it, but that is not a reason for them not to have it. It seems a lot of people can't make that distinction.CACBAND said:Nothing happens that causes a service vehicle to need to be yielded too. If they can't exceed the limit why not just go with the flow of traffic. What does that truck have hidden in the camper that a PD or FD truck does not have, that will save a life or property?
That's not what I said, but yes absolutely.CACBAND said:So if there's no reason for them not to have it, they should???
You do realize how ridiculous you sound, right? You again mistook a reason for ("I think...") for a reason against (Reason for the law) in your sarcastic (I say sarcastic instead of satiric because it's a logical fallacy) example. But since it's now apparent you don't have the mental capability of making this distinction, I will explain to others reading this post. This is America, where the law is framed by inclusion (You can be prosecuted for ____) rather than exclusion (You can't be prosecuted for ____), for now anyway. The purpose of lights is safety, not uniformity. No POV can have red/blue and no unmarked police cruiser can use red w/o blue in PA because they don't want people to be able to impersonate police, a public safety issue. Of course when you factor in lobbyists (like FDNY and green courtesy lights, or PCAA and only police are allowed to have slicktops in PA) this changes, but what can you do 99% of people are territorial.CACBAND said:Wee I think red/blue HAWs would cause people to slow down for people with flat tires, maybe they that should be a new OEM requirement, red/blue to the rear only with the 4 ways?
A riding mower/couch/mattress/large metal pipe/ car from a wrecker/tow truck or even stalled vehicles is all just a FEW examples of what happens everyday at any given time on any highway/interstate and is the reason why a DOT Incident response truck needs to be yield to for us to do our job and get to the scene and clear it from the lane before you or or family come across it crashing into it getting hurt or even killed.. I can only speak for SCDOT incident response trucks, but we have traffic cones, matjack air bag to jack up anything up to 50 tons pretty quickly which is mainly used when we assist people changing a flat tire. a few sockets/tools, air tools/gun, 5 gallon can of fuel, CPR/first aid kits, and water & abc fire extinguisher.... FIRE/EMS will not be dispatched out to prevent a crash/accident!! I have been dispatched to a stalled vehicle blocking the center lane out of a curve where a EMS truck come across it and they pulled over on the shoulder with their lights trying to warn people before they crash into this stalled car... but guess who shows up with a message/arrow board and push bumper to safely push this mini van to the shoulder of the road while controlling traffic at the same time before it got smashed by a car/truck or even an 18 wheeler! Yep DOT incident response!!! So by clearing the lane of travel from whatever that is blocking it to a moving stalled vehicle to the shoulder and out of the lane of travel and thus preventing a crash is how we save lives and property!!!CACBAND said:Nothing happens that causes a service vehicle to need to be yielded too. If they can't exceed the limit why not just go with the flow of traffic. What does that truck have hidden in the camper that a PD or FD truck does not have, that will save a life or property?
stansdds said:I'd like to know why a DOT thinks it needs to run red and white warning lights, do they think they are fire/ems?
Shep0968 said:
lafd55 said:Oh man, love the blue on that SCDOT truck and can't believe it's factory! Not a fan of the new console setup though, looks like a bitch to reach anything, should have stuck with a full length or custom one.
R-Rizzo said:First of all, I apologize for bumping such an old thread. Just thought it would be perfect for my first post as I am a part of this program.
To begin, that is not one of our trucks. Only thing I can think of is that maybe it was a mock-up or a test run. We run F-350's very very similar to Shep in SC's Blue Beauty. Only we have a covered pull out joey bed that contains the majority of our gear.
Also wanted to touch on the whole Lights and Sirens issue. I know for people in other states where it's not the norm, it is very weird / almost sacriledge for a DOT truck to have L/S. But as others have pointed out, we are certified emergency vehicles with the state. For a couple of reasons. #1 is in the metro area. We would not be able to get ANYWHERE with out the ability to push traffic run the shoulder. #2 in my metro area, we are the first responders for all non injury and unk injury veh crashes. We are a self reporting state and if it's not a trauma inj / the cops really have other things they could be doing. We have diesel transfer pumps and a 50 gallon tank on board for diesel pump offs. Oregon being such a green state, any hazmat diesel incident are automatic code runs for us.
And also just want to send a little shout out to Shawn L who works right down the road from me. His agency is good people. If anyone has any questions feel free to ask.
CACBAND said:Nothing happens that causes a service vehicle to need to be yielded too. If they can't exceed the limit why not just go with the flow of traffic. What does that truck have hidden in the camper that a PD or FD truck does not have, that will save a life or property?
whypics2 said:Any chance you could post some pictures of your rig? Seems almost every time I drive through Oregon I see one of the incident response trucks somewhere on I-5, they look pretty slick from a distance