Another Q wiring question

NC Firefighter

New Member
Jul 26, 2010
4
North Carolina, USA
I'm about to be installing the first Q for my department and I've got a question. I've got a good basic understanding of vehicle wiring and I'm familiar with using relays and silinoids. My question is this how should I go about fusing the whole thing? I would think a circuit breaker but I've never actually looked at how one is wired. And how many amps would it need to break at? I've read they run at 100 but can pull around 200 on startup. So I figured I'd ask the experts.
 

SurfCityCar2

Member
May 20, 2010
156
Jacksonville, NC
We just intalled a Q2B on one of our existing pumpers. The main thing to remember is the wiring sizes.


From the battery to the line lug on the solenoid is 4ga battery cable, as well as from the load side of the solenoid to the main lug on the Q2B.


For the brake, we ran 10ga wire with a smaller solenoid controlling that.


We fused the main power line feeding the line side of the solenoid with a 200 amp non-self resetting circuit breaker and haven't had any problems with it, since all of my guys LOVE to "ride the Q" all the way to the call.


The main power feeding the brake circuit is fused for 20 amps, just to include some breathing room...


Make sure the solenoid you get the main power for the Q is rated for continuous duty and lots of amps.


Federal Signal had a wiring kit available through their dealers, as that is where we got the breaker, solenoid and switches from...
 

NC Firefighter

New Member
Jul 26, 2010
4
North Carolina, USA
Wow good info guys. I had looked at the install sheet for it but I didn't notice the 300 amp fuse, but after looking closer I found it in the diagram. I have found and ordered the factory wiring kit and it sounds like it should have everything but the solenoid and the cable. I can get the cable here in town but the biggest cont. duty solenoid I've found anywhere, including online, is 85 amps. If anybody could give me an idea where to get one that'd be great.
 

Henry455

Member
May 21, 2010
513
Houston, TX
You might want to contact Cole Hersee regarding this relay, what has me concerned is the statement "200A carry only", the specs say nothing about the make and break amp ratings as do all their other relays.


Specifications


Special Applications High current. Utility vehicles, winches, lift trucks, snow plows etc.


Insulated/Grounded Insulated


NO/NC normally open


Min Qty No


Circuitry SPST


Contacts silver


Housing plated steel


Voltage Rating 12V


Terminals copper; 10-32 thread and 5/16"-24 thread. Hex nuts and lock washers included


Continuous Rating 200A carry only


Intermittent Time Not applicable: continuous


Bracket Straight


Bracket Mounting Holes 5/16" x 19/32", 2-13/64" on center


Breather Hole no


UL Marine & CE ISO 8846 Marine Not listed
 

NC Firefighter

New Member
Jul 26, 2010
4
North Carolina, USA
Well I've looked over the wiring kit install sheet again and it looks like it indeed does not come with a relay or solenoid of any kind, at least from the one I found online. Does anybody know what apparatus use from the factory to run the Q? I don't have easy access to one or I'd just go look. Also what seems to be the issue with just a simple starter relay from the parts store? I would think that it would be fine since the Q siren is fairly intermittent current with the winding up and coasting. They all seem to be rated for 750 amps make and at least 100 carry. I'm not trying to be smarter than the rest or anything, just thinking out loud here trying to figure this out. I'm used to dealing with much lighter loads of around 40 amps or less with lights and such.
 

shues

Lifetime VIP Donor
May 21, 2010
10,300
NW Indiana
Using a starter solenoid to operate a Q is a poor idea because of the way a Q is used. The usage pattern of a Q siren does not model that of an automobile starter at all. A starter relay is used once for just few seconds to start a vehicle, and usually has hours to cool off before it is called upon again to start the vehicle.


Think about your average response. Is it 5 minutes, 10 minutes, more? Is the Q wound up just once for the whole response. Probably not. It's probably wound up and let to coast at least a half a dozen times and probably more, depending on the time of day and the demographics of your response area. Just imagine how quickly your starter solenoid would go out if you had to use it to start the car at every intersection.


Everybody has heard someone who will "ride" the Q. This is especially bad for an intermittent duty solenoid like a starter solenoid. The solenoid never gets a break while someone is "riding" the Q, and can get very hot very quickly. Just imagine how quickly your starter solenoid would go out if you had to run the starter for your whole trip to the grocery store.


It is the nature of how a Q siren is used that indicates the need for a continuous duty solenoid.
 

Henry455

Member
May 21, 2010
513
Houston, TX
I have to respectively disagree with your statement. A continuous duty solenoid especially, one rated at 85 amps, is not made to make and break every 20-30 seconds with a 100- 200+ amp load (200+ inrush current), the contacts will not withstand the arcing after a while. A starter solenoid contacts are designed to take up to 700+ amps without serious contact erosion. I have had a Q for over 35 years and am still using the same starter relay to operate it. You can run the Q continuous for over a minute and the solenoid does not even get warm, I am pulling an average of a little over 100 amps through a solenoid rated for 750 amps, thus little or no heat is produced.
 

SurfCityCar2

Member
May 20, 2010
156
Jacksonville, NC
shues said:
When high current automotive switching comes to mind, so should Cole Hersee. You may want to get a Cole Hersee 24143, which is a 200 amp 12 volt continuous duty solenoid.

It's on the top of page 2 in this PDF of their catalog: http://www.colehersee.com/pdf/master_cat/e_solenoid.PDF
Cole Hersee is all I use for high current switching. Battery disconnects and solenoids from CH are great stuff.


We are running the very solenoid mentioned above for the mainline make/break for our Q and haven't had any problems for quite some time now.


CH makes a great solenoid for POV use, that is an 85 (IIRC) continuous duty solenoid. I have installed one in each of my POVs over the years and never had a problem.


As far as a dealer for Cole Hersee, any local shop that sells part for or works on heavy equipment or tractor-trailer trucks should be able to get their stuff. I happen to have Triple-T parts and service just down the road from me. They sell and service tractor-trailers and heavy trucks. Good prices too....
 

Phillyrube

Member
May 21, 2010
1,272
Flatistan
Henry455 said:
I have to respectively disagree with your statement. A continuous duty solenoid especially, one rated at 85 amps, is not made to make and break every 20-30 seconds with a 100- 200+ amp load (200+ inrush current), the contacts will not withstand the arcing after a while. A starter solenoid contacts are designed to take up to 700+ amps without serious contact erosion. I have had a Q for over 35 years and am still using the same starter relay to operate it. You can run the Q continuous for over a minute and the solenoid does not even get warm, I am pulling an average of a little over 100 amps through a solenoid rated for 750 amps, thus little or no heat is produced.

I used a plain old starter solenoid, and ran ran single wire to the foot pedals, so the switch grounded the circuit and closed the solenoid.
 

BackYardSales

Member
Dec 5, 2011
445
US - KY
shues said:
Everybody has heard someone who will "ride" the Q. This is especially bad for an intermittent duty solenoid like a starter solenoid. The solenoid never gets a break while someone is "riding" the Q, and can get very hot very quickly. Just imagine how quickly your starter solenoid would go out if you had to run the starter for your whole trip to the grocery store.

It is the nature of how a Q siren is used that indicates the need for a continuous duty solenoid.

Since somebody dug up an old thread...... I've never heard a Q in a constant "On" mode. You hit and release, hit and release, hit and release, sometimes holding for a few seconds trying to make it sing. It's the rising and falling tone at differing rates that commands attention like no other siren can. There were times when I could almost tell who was driving by the way they played the Q. Everybody does it different.


I hated when they came out with the brake. I can remember walking by a rig quite a while after it was parked and still hearing the Q winding down.
 

ryan81986

Member
Apr 13, 2011
525
Boston, MA
I think hes referring to people who put their foot on the pedal when they get in the truck and dont take it off until they get on scene. There are a few of them out there.
 

Skip Goulet

Member
Feb 23, 2011
4,241
Midland, TX
shues said:
Using a starter solenoid to operate a Q is a poor idea because of the way a Q is used. The usage pattern of a Q siren does not model that of an automobile starter at all. A starter relay is used once for just few seconds to start a vehicle, and usually has hours to cool off before it is called upon again to start the vehicle.

Think about your average response. Is it 5 minutes, 10 minutes, more? Is the Q wound up just once for the whole response. Probably not. It's probably wound up and let to coast at least a half a dozen times and probably more, depending on the time of day and the demographics of your response area. Just imagine how quickly your starter solenoid would go out if you had to use it to start the car at every intersection.


Everybody has heard someone who will "ride" the Q. This is especially bad for an intermittent duty solenoid like a starter solenoid. The solenoid never gets a break while someone is "riding" the Q, and can get very hot very quickly. Just imagine how quickly your starter solenoid would go out if you had to run the starter for your whole trip to the grocery store.


It is the nature of how a Q siren is used that indicates the need for a continuous duty solenoid.

I have to disagree with what you say. The old-style Ford solenoids have been used for motor sirens for many, many years. You don't want, nor do you need, a continuous duty solenoid to run a Q or any other motordriven siren. Many years ago I took one of our ambulances to a local auto electric co. that I had used in the past, to have a Q mounted and wired. The tech, who was relatively new, used a continuous duty solenoid, it ended up frying the brushes on the siren, and it cost his shop a bit of money for the Q repair and solenoid replacement.
 

bpollard

Member
Jun 13, 2010
425
USA, SC
If you have a shop or dealer around that sells and services golf carts, they can help you out. Golf carts (electric) use high current solenoids to power the drive motors.


I don't thing a solenoid caused the brushes in your siren to burn up. I think the guy with his foot standing on the button did.
 

Wailer

Member
May 24, 2010
2,294
Canada
ryan81986 said:
I think hes referring to people who put their foot on the pedal when they get in the truck and dont take it off until they get on scene. There are a few of them out there.

Macho siren operators.
 

theolog

Member
Dec 27, 2010
731
North Carolina
ryan81986 said:
I think hes referring to people who put their foot on the pedal when they get in the truck and dont take it off until they get on scene. There are a few of them out there.

Haha, more than a few, unfortunately! And they're all over YouTube. They make me wanna revoke their siren license after punching them in the throat.
 

Forum Statistics

Threads
54,168
Messages
450,502
Members
19,179
Latest member
Ragnarok

About Us

  • Since 1997, eLightbars has been the premier venue for all things emergency warning equipment. Discussions, classified listings, pictures, videos, chat, & more! Our staff members strive to keep the forums organized and clutter-free. All of our offerings are free-of-charge with all costs offset by banner advertising. Premium offerings are available to improve your experience.

User Menu

Secure Browsing & Transactions

eLightbars.org uses SSL to secure all traffic between our server and your browsing device. All browsing and transactions within are secured by an SSL Certificate with high-strength encryption.