Thats about an hour away from me. Technically they are all in different towns and different zip codes, so if it was dispatched to the right place it shouldn't be a problem. But the numbers on montauk highway should keep restarting, it should be one continuous run. Except where it changes names from Merrick Rd to Montauk Hwy.
I think every decent sized town in suburban America has address woes like this. In my town we have streets of the same names but different types. For example we have Ocean Ave, Ocean Ct, Ocean St, etc, etc. And a bunch of out of sequence numbers.