lafd55 said:
But Mototrbo is a digital radio, just not P25. Just to specify a little bit.
Mototrbo(XPR radios) are, in my eyes, geared more towards businesses rather than public safety. XTS/XTLs are not that hard to find and not overwhelmingly expensive. Just watch out for Ebay radios, as some are refurbished with Chinese parts, instead look on here, RadioReference, and Batboards.
Correct. Motorola has done their best to keep a clear delineation between P25 for public safety and TRBO for business. Be careful about used radios on trunking systems... many have illegitimate serial numbers, and this can lead to some issues if your system administrator tracks such things. They should also be fully aligned, as many have been poorly hacked.
foxtrot5 said:
Someone please explain this to my asst. chief. We've got XPR6350's in the trucks as portables on an ANALOG VHF system. The damn things suck.
How so? The TRBO radios are actually pretty well built. The newer series (7550s, etc.) actually run the same processor and mostly the same RF as the APX series.
DJIceman97 said:
We have an XPR4550 UHF in our engine, which was in anticipation of the county going to MotoTRBO. One local PD uses them (my buddy also has one for interop on a larger scene) and the sound quality is MUCH cleaner than P25, and the analog seems to be a bit better than our XTL's.
TRBO uses the AMBE codec, which is a substantial improvement over IMBE. P25 Phase 2 uses the same codec and the audio sounds comparable. Also, the newer radios (APX, 7550, etc.) have better noise cancellation which makes the overall audio sound better.
Skip Goulet said:
Kindly explain Mototrbo! I understand analog systems, trunking systems, and APCO P25. But some of these new systems and encryption capabilities are beyond me.
Chinese parts is an understatement! My Pro2096 digital scanner bit the dust a few weeks ago and Radio Shack couldn't repair it, claiming "parts not available", and it's less than 3 yrs old.
Mototrbo is just another digital mode. It's available in a few flavors:
Standalone - just a basic repeater, except you have two talk paths (2-slot TDMA)
IP Site Connect - two or more basic repeaters, linked together via the Internet or private IP backhaul. Good for situations like power plants, where you want to link two sites together but don't really care about seamless roaming.
Capacity Plus - up to four repeaters interfaced together, for a total of 8 talk paths.
Linked Capacity Plus - Capacity Plus plus IP Site Connect.
Connect Plus - a wide-area, seamless roaming solution. Similar to Passport, Smartzone, and wide area P25 systems. Requires a controller and has a continuous data channel (one slot).
The air interface is AMBE at a 4.8Kbps gross data rate per slot (2.45Kbps voice, 1.15Kbps FEC, 1.2Kbps low speed data). Channel bandwidth is 12.5KHz, but the system meets the 6.25Khz ultra-narrow guidelines by equivalence (12.5K, but 2 slots/2 simultaneous talk paths).
It's actually a very well thought out system.